The CEO of Goodwill Industries International, Steven C. Preston, was reported at roughly $600,000 to $650,000 in compensation on the organization’s IRS Form 990 filings, with a little more in benefits. That is a fraction of the $1 million-plus figures that circulate on many websites, and it covers only the head of the international umbrella group. Goodwill is not one company. It is a network of about 155 independent local organizations, each with its own board and its own CEO, and local pay varies widely, so there is no single Goodwill CEO salary.
Who is the CEO of Goodwill?
Steven C. Preston is president and CEO of Goodwill Industries International, known as GII, which is based in Rockville, Maryland. He took over from James Gibbons in January 2019. GII does not run the stores you shop in. It is the membership organization that supports the network of local Goodwills, sets standards, provides training and runs national programs. Each local Goodwill, such as Goodwill of North Georgia or Goodwill of Colorado, is a separate nonprofit with its own governing board, its own tax filings and its own chief executive, who is paid according to decisions made locally.
That distinction explains much of the confusion around the topic. When people talk about the Goodwill CEO’s salary online, they may be talking about the head of GII, about the head of one local organization, or about an average across the network. Those are three very different numbers.
What the tax filings show for Steven Preston
Nonprofits that file a Form 990 must list the compensation of their highest-paid officers. A yearly review of Goodwill filings by the Paddock Post reported that Preston’s compensation was $605,362 in the 2021 filing and $650,989 in a later filing. For comparison, his predecessor Gibbons was listed with a salary of $598,300 plus $118,927 in additional compensation in 2017. ProPublica’s Nonprofit Explorer, which digitizes IRS data, lists Preston with $632,016 in reportable compensation and $53,284 in other compensation in one of the filings it covers. The year on that listing should be checked when you open it, since several years are available.
The other executives at GII are paid considerably less. The same ProPublica listing shows the chief mission officer at $332,387, the chief operating officer at $331,593 and the chief marketing officer at $331,056. The Paddock Post review also found that GII had 193 employees who were paid a total of about $22 million, an average of roughly $114,000, and that only 67 of them earned more than $100,000.
Why you see much higher numbers online
Search results for the Goodwill CEO’s salary include many pages that quote $750,000, $850,000, $1.1 million, $1.2 million, $1.4 million or even $2.3 million. We could not match those numbers to the Form 990 data. Many of the pages appear to be generated automatically, give no source for their figures, and contradict one another. One of them describes a total package of about $1.19 million, another says $1.4 million, and a third says the range is $750,000 to $1.2 million.
Goodwill has addressed one of these claims itself. On its accountability page, Goodwill says that its international president and CEO does not make $2.3 million a year and points readers to its annual report and tax filings. The safest approach is to treat any figure that does not cite a specific Form 990 and year as unreliable.
Local Goodwill CEOs are paid differently
The 155 or so local Goodwill organizations are independent, and their CEOs’ pay depends on the size of the organization, its revenue, its region and its board’s decisions. A local Goodwill that runs dozens of stores and large job-training programs may pay its CEO far more than a small one. Several local Goodwills publish their filings and explain their pay on their own websites; one in Tennessee, for example, points readers to its own 990 and names its own CEO, which is different from the head of GII.
This also explains why headlines about Goodwill executive pay can be misleading. A report that a single local Goodwill paid its chief executive a particular amount says nothing about the others, and it does not describe the international group. If you want to know about a specific organization, look at that organization’s own filings.
How to check the numbers yourself
The filings are free and public. ProPublica’s Nonprofit Explorer lets you search for an organization by name and shows summaries of each Form 990 it has digitized, including a table of the highest-compensated officers. GuideStar and Charity Navigator also provide the filings. In the Form 990, the pay of the CEO and other key employees is reported in Part VII, which lists base pay, bonus, other reportable compensation, and benefits. Look at the year of the filing, because nonprofit returns are usually filed well after the period they cover.
Keep in mind that the headline figure in a Form 990 can include different things from one year to the next, such as a one-off bonus or deferred pay. That can make year-to-year changes look larger or smaller than a change in the underlying salary.
Is the pay reasonable for a nonprofit?
Nonprofit leaders are typically paid less than chief executives of large companies, but more than the average employee. US tax rules require that compensation at a tax-exempt organization be reasonable, and boards usually set pay with the help of comparisons against similar-sized charities. Supporters of high nonprofit pay argue that running a large federation needs experienced leadership, while critics argue that donors and the public expect charities to keep executive pay low. Goodwill is also a special case because the organization earns most of its revenue by selling donated goods and has a mission of providing job training, so its pay decisions attract more attention than those of some other charities.
Putting the figures in context
It helps to compare the head of Goodwill Industries International with the other kinds of leaders in the network. GII is a membership organization, so its CEO is accountable to a national board and to the local Goodwills that belong to it, and the role involves representing the whole network, setting standards and running programs that no single local organization could run alone. The local CEOs, by contrast, are responsible for stores, donation centers, workforce programs and employees in a defined region, and some of them oversee large local workforces. Because the two kinds of job differ, the pay for each is set differently, and the figure for one should never be used to describe the other.
The wider point is that a Form 990 figure is a snapshot of what one board decided in one year. It tells you what the person was paid, not whether the pay was justified. Readers who want to judge that for themselves can compare the number with the size of the organization, its revenue and the number of people it serves, all of which are also reported on the same form.
What to watch next
The next Form 990 for GII will add another year to the record. The key things to check are whether Preston’s reported compensation continues to sit around the same level and whether any of the other executives are paid more. For any local Goodwill you care about, look for its latest filing, which will normally be posted by ProPublica within a year or so of the end of the tax year.
Frequently asked questions
How much does the Goodwill CEO make?
The head of Goodwill Industries International, Steven C. Preston, was reported at about $605,000 in the 2021 Form 990 and about $651,000 in a later one. Local Goodwill CEOs are paid separately.
Does the Goodwill CEO make millions?
Goodwill says its international CEO does not make $2.3 million a year. The Form 990 figures we found are well below $1 million.
Who is the CEO of Goodwill?
Steven C. Preston has led Goodwill Industries International since January 2019.
Why does each Goodwill have its own CEO?
Local Goodwills are independent nonprofits with their own boards. Goodwill Industries International supports them but does not run them.
Where can I check?
ProPublica’s Nonprofit Explorer and the IRS Form 990 filings for each organization.
Sources
Figures were checked on 6 November 2026. We’ll update this page when new Form 990 data is published.

